/cdn.vox-cdn.com/imported_assets/1198201/2011-01-22_18.08.05.jpg)
In my article about the players' need for a second version of the WHA in order to regain leverage in their battle against NHL owners, dawgbone commented with a well-thought out critique:
I just don’t think you have the arena infrastructure in place to launch such a league.
First of all, it can’t get into the right markets. Unlike the WHA (who could get into spots like Western Canada and Ottawa/Quebec), there’s nowhere for these new clubs to go. Your only real option is Hamilton (depending on the various arena agreements the clubs have). I mean there are a couple of other options like London and Quebec City (old Colisee), but I just don’t think those are enough.
Not only that, but the WHA had the benefit of paying players between 30-150k each, a rival league would need to spend into the millions.
After the jump, I delve into the first of his criticisms - arena infrastructure and markets.
While most arenas are tied into NHL leases (another dimension of muni-funded arenas), there are a number of compatible arenas available to a second league. They are not suited to compete in the NHL, but they may be compatible with a second league. And while dawgbone doesn't see new markets for the new league, I believe the available arenas are located in markets that could support teams in a second league. Below is a list of 18 markets, their hockey venue and seating capacity for hockey:
City | Venue | Capacity |
Chicago | Allstate Arena | 16,692 |
Cincinnati | U.S. Bank Arena | 14,453 |
Columbus | Value City Arena | 17,500 |
Detroit | The Palace | 20,804 |
Halifax | Metro Centre | 10,595 |
Hamilton | Copps Coliseum | 17,383 |
Houston | Toyota Center | 17,800 |
Indianapolis | Market Square Arena | 15,993 |
Kansas City | Sprint Center | 17,544 |
Milwaukee | Bradley Center | 17,845 |
New York | Barclays Center | 14,500 |
Portland | Rose Garden | 18,280 |
Quebec | Pepsi Coliseum | 15,176 |
Saskatoon | Credit Union Centre | 15,195 |
Seattle | Key Arena | 15,177 |
Toronto | Ricoh Coliseum | 8,140 |
Tulsa | BOK Center | 17,096 |
Vancouver | Pacific Coliseum | 16,281 |
The buildings are varied as some are quite new with all of the amenities of an NHL arena, while some are outdated or quite small. But the potential exists - there are available facilities and markets. Given these markets, is the pool of potential owners large enough to create and maintain a competitive and financially viable league?