clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

What Does Tom Gilbert Mean To The Oilers?

via <a href="">Wikimedia Commons</a>, public domain
via Wikimedia Commons, public domain

There exists a certain type of fan that will never understand Tom Gilbert's value as a defender. No amount of possession metrics, scoring chance totals or WOWY breakdowns will convince them that Tom Gilbert is amongst the very best defenders in the NHL. Until Gilbert rings up points by the dozen, he will be rated as overpaid and unreliable by that cross-section. No amount of qualcomp, qualteam or block stats will convince them of Gilbert's toughness. Until Gilbert racks up highlight-worthy hits, he will be soft and uncaring in the minds of the faithful.

But one stat that should matter to everyone is the Oilers' record and goal differential without Gilbert.

Since losing Gilbert to a knee injury thanks to the useless Daniel Carcillo, the Oilers have won just one of eight games. The team's goal differential is -17 in those eight games.

In the 39 games prior to Gilbert's injury, the Oilers won 16 games and had a goal differential of -3.

Pre-injury 39 16 19 3 -3
Post-injury 8 1 7 1 -17

Even if the unsustainable hot streak at the beginning of the season is discounted, the difference is still remarkable.

Hot Streak 14 8 4 2 11 1.286 0.786
Pre-injury 25 8 15 1 -14 0.680 -0.560
Post-injury 8 1 7 1 -17 0.375 -2.125

When Ryan Batty named Tom Gilbert the Oilers' first-half MVP, it was well-deserved, but I don't think even he realized how valuable Gilbert was to the Oilers.