clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Edmonton Oilers' Prospect Rankings Comparison

New, comments
Photo by Lisa McRitchie, all rights reserved.
Photo by Lisa McRitchie, all rights reserved.

Hockey's Future has released their updated Oilers' prospect rankings, and unsurprisingly, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins is at the top.  In order to compare it to our Top 25 Under 25 rankings, we'd have to eliminate the players Hockeysfuture has denoted as graduated.  But rather than just compare our rankings to those at Hockey's Future, we decided to compare our rankings to Lowetide's Top 20 Prospects and those from the relentlessly upbeat Smokin' Ray at Oilers Jambalaya as well.


C&B Hockeysfuture Lowetide Oilers' Jambalaya
1 Ryan Nugent-Hopkins Ryan Nugent-Hopkins Ryan Nugent-Hopkins Ryan Nugent-Hopkins
2 Jeff Petry Jeff Petry Oscar Klefbom Jeff Petry
3 Anton Lander Oscar Klefbom Jeff Petry Anton Lander
4 Teemu Hartikainen Anton Lander Curtis Hamilton Oscar Klefbom
5 Oscar Klefbom Martin Marincin Teemu Hartikainen Teemu Hartikainen
6 Martin Marincin Curtis Hamilton Anton Lander Martin Marincin
7 Curtis Hamilton David Musil Martin Marincin Curtis Hamilton
8 Tyler Pitlick Teemu Hartikainen David Musil David Musil
9 Ryan Martindale Tyler Pitlick Tyler Bunz Tyler Bunz
10 David Musil Tyler Bunz Tyler Pitlick Colten Teubert
11 Brandon Davidson Jeremie Blain Olivier Roy Tyler Pitlick
12 Jeremie Blain Ryan Martindale Jeremie Blain Dillon Simpson
13 Colten Teubert Olivier Roy Chris Vandevelde Ryan Martindale
14 Dillon Simpson Colten Teubert Tobias Rieder Olivier Roy
15 Olivier Roy Travis Ewanyk Colten Teubert Travis Ewanyk
16 Samu Perhonen Alex Plante Brandon Davidson Jeremie Blain
17 Alex Plante Dillon Simpson Samu Perhonen Chris Vandevelde
18 Chris Vandevelde Tobias Rieder Alex Plante Alex Plante
19 Tyler Bunz Brandon Davidson Martin Gernat Ryan O'Marra
20 Tobias Rieder
Ryan Martindale Johan Motin

 

Nugent-Hopkins is the obvious choice at the top for each of us and Jeff Petry is ranked no lower than third, so they are the consensus top two.

The Copper and Blue has five players ranked higher than the others (Hartikainen, Pitlick, Martindale, Davidson, Perhonen), Hockey's Future has four (Marincin, Musil, Blain, Plante), Lowetide has six (Klefbom, Hamilton, Roy, Vandevelde, Rieder, Gernat), and Oilers Jambalaya has four (Teubert, Simpson, O'Marra, Motin).

The combined rankings are below; the table is sortable by column header.


C&B Hockey's Future Lowetide Oilers Jambalaya
Ryan Nugent-Hopkins 1 1 1 1
Jeff Petry 2 2 3 2
Oscar Klefbom 5 3 2 4
Anton Lander 3 4 6 3
Teemu Hartikainen 4 8 5 5
Curtis Hamilton 7 6 4 7
Martin Marincin 6 5 7 6
David Musil 10 7 8 8
Tyler Pitlick 8 9 10 11
Tyler Bunz 19 10 9 9
Jeremie Blain 12 11 12 16
Colten Teubert 13 14 15 10
Olivier Roy 15 13 11 14
Ryan Martindale 9 12 20 13
Alex Plante 17 16 18 18
Dillon Simpson 14 17
12
Brandon Davidson 11 19 16
Chris Vandevelde 18
13 17
Tobias Rieder 20 18 14
Travis Ewanyk
15
15
Samu Perhonen 16
17
Martin Gernat

19
Ryan O`Marra


19
Johan Motin


20