Scoring Chances WOWY: Defense & Forwards

I received the following e-mail from a regular lurking reader:

I'm a big fan of the scoring chances stuff you've been posting, especially the recent WOWY posts.  You have done forward combinations and some defensive combinations but unless I missed the post, you have never looked at forward and defenders together and apart.  Is that difficult to do?  If not, I want to see how forwards do without Whitney since he plays so much ice time.

Rather than look at just Ryan Whitney, I've done a WOWY for each regular defender with every forward to appear for the Oilers this season.  After the jump, you'll find that information, presented without analysis, for your review.  If you find anything interesting, please use the comments section to point it out or present it for discussion.  I believe the sample size involved in this data is too small to find meaningful information on a large scale, though probably large enough to detect a trend or two throughout the group. 

If there are any additional scoring chance WOWY comparisons you'd like to see, let me know.  I can perform lookups on any number of combinations using goaltender, forward or defense or combining all of them.

Jim Vandermeer

	With Vandermeer				Without Vandermeer				Vandermeer Without
#	CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%
4	35	28	0.556		102	115	0.470		52	86	0.377
10	23	26	0.469		74	68	0.521		64	88	0.421
13	23	27	0.460		67	101	0.399		64	87	0.424
14	28	37	0.431		106	103	0.507		59	77	0.434
16	6	19	0.240		24	51	0.320		81	95	0.460
22	3	8	0.273		8	17	0.320		84	106	0.442
23	0	3	0.000		1	14	0.067		87	111	0.439
27	28	26	0.519		77	79	0.494		59	88	0.401
28	9	26	0.257		38	70	0.352		78	88	0.470
33	0	3	0.000		2	5	0.286		87	111	0.439
42	0	3	0.000		0	10	0.000		87	111	0.439
46	6	10	0.375		17	28	0.378		81	104	0.438
67	16	29	0.356		52	82	0.388		71	85	0.455
83	26	18	0.591		56	63	0.471		61	96	0.389
89	34	38	0.472		84	94	0.472		53	76	0.411
91	24	41	0.369		53	94	0.361		63	73	0.463

 

 

Ladislav Smid

	With Smid				Without Smid				Smid Without
#	CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%
4	34	45	0.430		103	98	0.512		56	79	0.415
10	20	17	0.541		77	77	0.500		70	107	0.395
13	26	45	0.366		64	83	0.435		64	79	0.448
14	35	36	0.493		99	104	0.488		55	88	0.385
16	10	13	0.435		20	57	0.260		80	111	0.419
22	2	3	0.400		9	22	0.290		88	121	0.421
23	0	10	0.000		1	7	0.125		90	114	0.441
27	28	31	0.475		77	74	0.510		62	93	0.400
28	19	32	0.373		28	64	0.304		71	92	0.436
33	2	2	0.500		0	6	0.000		88	122	0.419
42	0	9	0.000		0	4	0.000		90	115	0.439
46	4	22	0.154		19	16	0.543		86	102	0.457
67	22	44	0.333		46	67	0.407		68	80	0.459
83	16	12	0.571		66	69	0.489		74	112	0.398
89	32	34	0.485		86	98	0.467		58	90	0.392
91	18	34	0.346		59	101	0.369		72	90	0.444

 

 

	With Whitney				Without Whitney				Whitney Without
#	CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%
4	55	58	0.487		82	85	0.491		89	111	0.445
10	36	51	0.414		61	43	0.587		108	118	0.478
13	36	46	0.439		54	82	0.397		108	123	0.468
14	48	59	0.449		86	81	0.515		96	110	0.466
16	9	23	0.281		21	47	0.309		135	146	0.480
22	8	5	0.615		3	20	0.130		136	164	0.453
23	0	3	0.000		1	14	0.067		144	166	0.465
27	40	39	0.506		65	66	0.496		104	130	0.444
28	19	29	0.396		28	67	0.295		125	140	0.472
33	0	3	0.000		2	5	0.286		144	166	0.465
42	0	1	0.000		0	12	0.000		144	168	0.462
46	6	17	0.261		17	21	0.447		138	152	0.476
67	29	36	0.446		39	75	0.342		115	133	0.464
83	46	36	0.561		36	45	0.444		98	133	0.424
89	59	49	0.546		59	83	0.415		85	120	0.415
91	43	50	0.462		34	85	0.286		101	119	0.459

 

Kurtis Foster

	With Foster				Without Foster				Foster Without
#	CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%
4	38	38	0.500		99	105	0.485		47	85	0.356
10	22	20	0.524		75	74	0.503		63	103	0.380
13	30	32	0.484		60	96	0.385		55	91	0.377
14	37	33	0.529		97	107	0.475		48	90	0.348
16	5	18	0.217		25	52	0.325		80	105	0.432
22	0	7	0.000		11	18	0.379		85	116	0.423
23	0	7	0.000		1	10	0.091		85	116	0.423
27	28	26	0.519		77	79	0.494		57	97	0.370
28	15	33	0.313		32	63	0.337		70	90	0.438
33	0	2	0.000		2	6	0.250		85	121	0.413
42	0	5	0.000		0	8	0.000		85	118	0.419
46	4	11	0.267		19	27	0.413		81	112	0.420
67	22	28	0.440		46	83	0.357		63	95	0.399
83	17	25	0.405		65	56	0.537		68	98	0.410
89	26	41	0.388		92	91	0.503		59	82	0.418
91	11	43	0.204		66	92	0.418		74	80	0.481

 

 

Jason Strudwick

	With Strudwick				Without Strudwick				Strudwick Without
#	CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%
4	15	20	0.429		122	123	0.498		19	32	0.373
10	5	12	0.294		92	82	0.529		29	40	0.420
13	11	18	0.379		79	110	0.418		23	34	0.404
14	14	20	0.412		120	120	0.500		20	32	0.385
16	6	6	0.500		24	64	0.273		28	46	0.378
22	0	0	#DIV/0!		11	25	0.306		34	52	0.395
23	0	1	0.000		1	16	0.059		34	51	0.400
27	7	13	0.350		98	92	0.516		27	39	0.409
28	5	7	0.417		42	89	0.321		29	45	0.392
33	2	2	0.500		0	6	0.000		32	50	0.390
42	0	0	#DIV/0!		0	13	0.000		34	52	0.395
46	5	5	0.500		18	33	0.353		29	47	0.382
67	6	10	0.375		62	101	0.380		28	42	0.400
83	7	10	0.412		75	71	0.514		27	42	0.391
89	13	16	0.448		105	116	0.475		21	36	0.368
91	6	15	0.286		71	120	0.372		28	37	0.431

 

 

Theo Peckham

	With Peckham				Without Peckham				Peckham Without
#	CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%
4	44	48	0.478		93	95	0.495		57	94	0.377
10	39	31	0.557		58	63	0.479		62	111	0.358
13	25	43	0.368		65	85	0.433		76	99	0.434
14	49	43	0.533		85	97	0.467		52	99	0.344
16	8	29	0.216		22	41	0.349		93	113	0.451
22	2	13	0.133		9	12	0.429		99	129	0.434
23	1	5	0.167		0	12	0.000		100	137	0.422
27	35	31	0.530		70	74	0.486		66	111	0.373
28	11	30	0.268		36	66	0.353		90	112	0.446
33	0	3	0.000		2	5	0.286		101	139	0.421
42	0	4	0.000		0	9	0.000		101	138	0.423
46	7	16	0.304		16	22	0.421		94	126	0.427
67	19	32	0.373		49	79	0.383		82	110	0.427
83	15	26	0.366		67	55	0.549		86	116	0.426
89	27	34	0.443		91	98	0.481		74	108	0.407
91	22	37	0.373		55	98	0.359		79	105	0.429

 

Tom Gilbert

	With Gilbert				Without Gilbert				Gilbert Without
#	CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%		CF	CA	%
4	47	46	0.505		90	97	0.481		82	112	0.423
10	44	30	0.595		53	64	0.453		85	128	0.399
13	26	45	0.366		64	83	0.435		103	113	0.477
14	51	49	0.510		83	91	0.477		78	109	0.417
16	16	29	0.356		14	41	0.255		113	129	0.467
22	7	10	0.412		4	15	0.211		122	148	0.452
23	1	5	0.167		0	12	0.000		128	153	0.456
27	42	40	0.512		63	65	0.492		87	118	0.424
28	15	34	0.306		32	62	0.340		114	124	0.479
33	0	1	0.000		2	7	0.222		129	157	0.451
42	0	4	0.000		0	9	0.000		129	154	0.456
46	11	12	0.478		12	26	0.316		118	146	0.447
67	21	42	0.333		47	69	0.405		108	116	0.482
83	35	32	0.522		47	49	0.490		94	126	0.427
89	42	48	0.467		76	84	0.475		87	110	0.442
91	29	46	0.387		48	89	0.350		100	112	0.472