The Oilers Are Building An International Defense
Aside from beginning two extremely (at least in Edmonton) popular franchise models, it seems like Detroit and Pittsburgh were also at the forefront of a trend - the international defense. Just two Canadian defenseman won the cup during those two years, and a look at the rosters shows a pair of teams heavily weighted with Americans on the blueline.
| Player |
Hometown |
Player |
Hometown |
|
| Brad Stuart | Rocky Mtn House, Alberta | Kris Letang | Montreal, Quebec | |
| Niklas Kronwall | Stockholm, Sweden | Sergei Gonchar | Chelyabinsk, Russia | |
| Nicklas Lidstrom | Vasteras, Sweden | Mark Eaton | Wilmington, Delaware | |
| Andreas Lilja | Helsingborg, Sweden | Hal Gill | Concord, Massachusetts | |
| Chris Chelios | Chicago, Illinois | Brooks Orpik | San Francisco, California | |
| Brett Lebda | Buffalo Grove, Illinois | Alex Goligoski | Grand Rapids, Michigan | |
| Brian Rafalski | Dearborn, Michigan | Rob Scuderi | Syosset, New York |
Detroit's top seven had an equal split of Swedes and Americans, with only late-season acquisition Brad Stuart representing Canada. Kris Letang was the only Canadian on the Pittsburgh defense, the other six consisted of one Russian and five Americans. It seemed the key to the cup, other than icing a pair of the best forwards in the world was to build an international defense. But the Chicago Blackhawks, the name of a hockey team and another popular franchise model, used a largely Canadian defense to win the cup.
| Player | Hometown |
| Brian Campbell | Strathroy, Ontario |
| Jordan Hendry | Nokomis, Saskatchewan |
| Duncan Keith | Winnipeg, Manitoba |
| Brent Seabrook | Richmond, British Columbia |
| Brent Sopel | Calgary, Alberta |
| Niklas Hjalmarsson | Eksjo, Sweden |
The Blackhawks used five Canadians and one Swede on their way to The Stanley Cup, reversing the mini-trend created by the Red Wings and Penguins.
The next supposed dynasty, the one with management that has self-admittedly (and supposedly) mirrored each of these models within the last two years is building a defense for the long term. Which of the three models will the Edmonton Oilers follow?

Theo Peckham - Richmond Hill, Ontario

Ladislav Smid - Frydlant V Cechach, The Czech Republic
Ryan Whitney - Boston, Massachusetts
Tom Gilbert - Bloomington, Minnesota
Jeff Petry - Farmington Hills, Michigan
With five defensemen set, there are two spots up for grabs. A number of prospects in the system are capable of filling those vacancies, but given the team is already well on it's way to the Pittsburgh defense and the Oilers have a Canadian on the roster, it's now doubtful that any of the following Canadian prospects will be a part of the eventual cup winner:
Jeremie Blain - Longueuil, Quebec
Taylor Chorney - Thunder Bay, Ontario
Brandon Davidson - Lethbridge, Alberta
Alex Plante - Brandon, Manitoba
Of course, the Oilers could trade Peckham, opening up a spot for one of the young native blueliners.
Martin Marincin - Kosice, Slovakia

Johan Motin - Kariskoga, Sweden
Kyle Bigos - Upland, California
Troy Hesketh - Minnetonka, Minnesota
The Pittsburgh defense consisted of five Americans, so both of these guys have a shot.

Roman Hamrlik - Zlin, The Czech Republic
Tomas Kaberle - Rakovnik, The Czech Republic
Jan Hejda - Prague, The Czech Republic
Radek Martinek - Havlicko Brod, The Czech Republic
Each of these Czechs are long in the tooth and probably not the best option for this dynasty. A younger, smarter, more Finnish option would make sense though.

Joni Pitkanen - Oulu, Finland
His first tour of duty in Edmonton ended with Pitkanen receiving a bum rap, but he remains a stud capable of playing twenty-six minutes a night and playing in all situations and he'll be 27 years old next season. Also - he's Finnish.

Andrei Markov - Voskresensk, Russia
Denis Grebeshkov - Yaroslavl, Russia

Jonathan Ericsson - Karlskrona, Sweden
Ericsson wasn't part of the Detroit Cup win, but he was part of the team that lost to the Penguins in the Cup finals in 2009.
Of course, the Oilers need to add more defensive depth in the draft and there is one player out there who solves both the issue of international defensive depth and more Finnish.

Jyrki Jokipakka - Tampere, Finland
I'll have more on Jokipakka as the draft approaches, but a smooth-skating, slick-passing Finnish defenseman used to be a staple of Edmonton Oilers hockey - it should be again.
Of course some, though not all, of this is tongue-in-cheek, the Oilers do have five defensemen set to handle the defensive duties for a number of years. If that's the case, what will the defense look like in 2011? What about 2012? Please feel free to leave your educated guesses, hockey fantasies and wild and crazy team-building trades in the comments.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Nice article Derek. Funny how the Oilers seem to, or at least did, value American defensemen (Whitney, Gilbert, Petry, Greene, Poti, Wild, Bigos, Hesketh, arguably Chorney*), and every single one of those went the NCAA route. Maybe just coincidence as most of those guys had obvious talents, but Lowe’s management always seemed to favour NCAA d-men, and it worked for a while too, although the whole Nash saga along with Chorney’s poor development has seen them sour on such a route. Marincin, Davidson and Blaine seem to have signalled the start of a new trend after the recent flops of Hesketh and Bigos (too early to call them busts, but ya know, they probably are).
*On a side note, Chorney’s an odd one, because although he’s Canadian he actually holds US citizenship too, I assume through his father Marc who played for Pittsburgh and LA, and has always played for the US internationally (including at last years WCs where he was hilariously included).
The Oilers signing Pitkanen would almost cause me to believe in this management team again. There is no possible way that’s going to happen.
Manager at Vancouver Whitecaps and western Canadian soccer website Eighty Six Forever and infrequently-posting flunky at Edmonton Oilers blog The Copper & Blue.
by Benjamin Massey on Jan 28, 2011 7:44 AM MST reply actions
I agree. There is no way oilers sign pitkanen
My fantasy sign/trade is weber.
Realistically, signing someone like Jovonaski for a couple of years or even wisnewiski.
Wisniewiski kinda reminds me of souray. Hard hitting physical d man capable of putting up points on the pp.of course his d coverage needs some work, but he 26!prime age to get d men
Rebuild is a convenient excuse for GMs who dont wish to do their jobs
"If only we had a guy that could make that first pass….", "when management realizes we need a d-man that can get the puck to the forwards….", "If we had a real PP quarterback…." "PMD, PMD, PMD……"
That train of thought was all the rage in 07. I haven’t really heard any of these clichés lately. Seems like since Gilbert grew up that we’ve had a sufficient "PMD" on each of the top two pairings. Souray, Lubo, and Whitney have all been that guy at one point, but (IMO) the most fun to watch of all of them has been the big Finn.
I would love to have him back here. Room him with Peckham, Joni has the skill and pays the bills, Theo handles the spunk and if anyone says anything bad about his brother Joni he punches them right in the junk.
Not that he would ever come back here.
I recognize the tongue-in-cheek nature of the article, but there’s quite a few NHL D that are starting to look like the UN. Take Montreal: three Canadians (Gorges, Subban, Picard), two Americans (Gill, Wisniewski), two Czechs (Hamrlik, Spacek), a Russian (Markov) and a Swiss (Weber).
I wonder what the most international team is, anyway: I wouldn’t be surprised if it was the one-time “Flying Frenchmen,” since they also have Belarus (Kostitsyn) and Denmark (Eller) represented, and recently had a Swede (Andreas Engqvist) on call-up.
SNN Sports - A theoretical Oilers blog (i.e. theoretically, I write stuff there). Link now 100% less broken.
The most international players or most countries represented?
The Pens defense still has only one regular Canadian – Letang. They have Martin, Orpik, Goligoski from the US and a Czech – Michalek. The final spot has been split between Engelland (Canada) and Lovejoy (US).
Editor of The Copper & Blue, and leader of The Cult Of Hartikainen.
Countries represented, is I guess what I was going for.
SNN Sports - A theoretical Oilers blog (i.e. theoretically, I write stuff there). Link now 100% less broken.
First off, I have to say that I’m generally not a fan of American defenseman. However, I think Bogosian is a guy you can build your back-end around. I think he’ll be a great defenseman. If he’s available, let’s throw something good to get him. This is the type that I can handle trading a guy like Hemmer for, as I think he’d be a key piece of the future.
Other rumors are that Ryan Ellis is available in Nashville (good all around player, but size could be an issue..), also the Fourth Period / Edmonton Journal suggest the Jackets are shopping Jan Hejda. I’d take Hejda in a lesser deal for sure. Apparently the Hawks are thinking about moving Brent Seabrook.
If Bogosian and Ellis are available, I wonder if there’s a chance we could get Pietrangelo out of St. Louis. It would be really nice and help solidify our rebuild if we had a franchise d-man to build around. Foster, Strudwick and Vandermeer should already be considered goners… but bringing in a big franchise d-man would allow us to push out a Gilbert or Smid slowly for guys like Marincin, etc.. that are in the system.
Visit [url="www.puttingonthefoil.com"]www.puttingonthefoil.com[/url]

by 

























