Unrestricted Free Agent Defensemen - Filling Out The Oilers Blueline
While there are serious needs at forward heading into the 2010-2011 season, the Oilers have a serious problem on the blueline, namely, they only have three NHL defensemen. Right now, the depth chart is lacking:
| Ryan Whitney | Tom Gilbert |
| ??????? | ??????? |
| Ladislav Smid | ??????? |
| Taylor Chorney | |
| Theo Peckham | |
| Jason Strudwick |
It's Ryan Whitney, Tom Gilbert, Ladislav Smid and a whole bunch of negative Corsi. The three guys competing for the title of "seventh defenseman on the worst team in the league" don't have much of a history of success in the NHL. In fact, two-thirds of them comprise the backbone of "The Shift", the longest shift in NHL history. Steve Tambellini has his work cut out for him.
I've previously linked to the interview I did at Red Light District Hockey when I discussed the Oilers' off-season plans, and the bit about the defense is still a framework for the defense:
If Sheldon Souray is traded at the draft, as he's expected to be, then the Oilers are going to need the most affordable second minutes defender with penalty killing experience in the class of Henrik Tallinder, Jordan Leopold, Zbynek Michalek, and Dennis Seidenberg. They're also going to have to find a low cap hit bottom pairing defender that can move the puck to pair with Ladislav Smid, guys like Kurtis Foster, Brian Pothier, and Carlo Colaiacovo fit the bill. Finally, they'll want a cap-minimum bottom-pairing defender for depth, and I'm expecting them to find one in the European leagues.
| NAME | POS | AGE | TEAM | CAP HIT | DETAILS |
| Carlo Colaiacovo | D | 27 | STL | $1,283,333 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Mark Eaton | D | 33 | PIT | $2,000,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Kurtis Foster | D | 28 | TBL | $600,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Denis Grebeshkov | D | 26 | NSH | $3,100,000 | Not Qualified |
| Aaron Johnson | D | 27 | EDM | $540,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Milan Jurcina | D | 27 | WAS | $1,375,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Brett Lebda | D | 28 | DET | $650,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Jordan Leopold | D | 29 | PIT | $1,750,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Andreas Lilja | D | 34 | DET | $1,250,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Toni Lydman | D | 32 | BUF | $2,875,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Freddy Meyer | D | 29 | NYI | $587,500 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Zbynek Michalek | D | 27 | PHO | $1,250,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Shaone Morrisonn | D | 27 | WAS | $1,975,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Brian Pothier | D | 33 | CAR | $2,500,000 | 2010 (UFA) |
| Henrik Tallinder | D | 31 | BUF | $2,562,500 | 2010 (UFA) |
The above list spans a number of different options, from older defensemen that may take a short-term contract like Mark Eaton and Brian Pothier. Both of them would be bottom pairing types, playing with Ladislav Smid. Other possible partners for Smid inclue Carlo Colaiacovo, Kurtis Foster, Milan Jurcina, and Freddy Meyer. The most attractive of them is Colaiacovo, the former first round pick who found a home on the bottom pairing with the Blues. If Tambellini were able to ink him to a long-term deal at a reasonable price, Colaiacovo could likely swing between the second and third pairings on the rebuilding Oilers.
The Oilers need to fill both spots on the second pairing and Grebeshkov, Leopold, Lydman, Michalek, Morrisonn and Tallinder would all work, but are they realistic options? We know how Michalek has been used in Phoenix -- he's the defensive version of Shawn Horcoff. With less of an own-zone and tough minutes load in the underlying stats, would he be more effective by the top line numbers? He's only 27 and offering him a five year contract isn't the worst idea - there are no stoppers except maybe Johan Motin anywhere in the Oilers' system right now - so Michalek fills a hole not only on the team but in the entire system as well. Lydman and Tallinder would be short-term fixes, but I have an inkling that Tallinder ends up a Red Wing come July 1st.
Another option is a return on Sheldon Souray. Right now, it's expected that the Oilers will be giving up a useful player or draft pick to move Souray to get something useful in return. However, it's also been suggested that the OIlers could move Souray and take back a more toxic contract with a useful player or pick. Think Brian Campbell or Wade Redden. Now cry.
The final option available to Steve Tambellini is an offer sheet. There are a number of defensemen headed to restricted free agency and the Oilers might be able to acquire them for a second round pick. Younger impact blueliners like Dan Girardi, Nicklas Grossman, Niklas Hjalmarsson, Kyle Quincey and Jeff Schultz are prime targets for an offer sheet, especially Grossman, as the Stars are operating on a hard budget, just a couple of million dollars above the salary floor. After being thrown to the wolves in his formative years, Grossman has become the go-to tough minutes guy in Dallas and he's shown that he can handle tough minutes, though not yet outscore them.
0 recs |
34 comments
|
Comments
Marc Staal is probably the best RFA defenseman at the moment—high qualcomp, low GAON/60.
Don’t want Joe Corvo? He’s another guy and at least in Carolina his advanced stats looked decent.
Cидни Kросби: Александр Oвечкин, он твой папа теперь
матовая Клими, Михал нуивирт ваш папа теперь
Red Line Station: for Capitals fans who can bear reading something less intelligent than a story at Japers' Rink
Follow me on Twitter!
you guys go away. Staal is pretty much already Canucks property as far as I’m concerned. :)
by Passive Voice on Jun 30, 2010 11:50 AM PDT up reply actions
Obviously, but Staal would cost a bundle via offer sheet.
As for Corvo, his limited skills are duplicated and bettered by both Gilbert and Whitney.
Editor of The Copper & Blue, and leader of The Cult Of Hartikainen.
Grossman would be a dream if we could steal him away from the Stars, but I don’t see it happening. Michalek would be an even bigger dream, but again, we’re not getting the top UFAs.
Another guy I like for the bottom pairing would be Mike Weaver in St.Louis. He’s a top notch penalty killer, but I find it absolutely impossible to believe the Oilers will have any interest at all in a 5’9" defenseman. < 6’ need not aply considering where these guys’ heads are at.
Grossman would be a dream if we could steal him away from the Stars, but I don’t see it happening. Michalek would
be an even bigger dream, but again, we’re not getting the top UFAs.
All things considered, I’d prefer Grossman.
Another guy I like for the bottom pairing would be Mike Weaver in St.Louis. He’s a top notch penalty killer, but I find it absolutely impossible to believe the Oilers will have any interest at all in a 5’9" defenseman. < 6’ need not aply considering where these guys’ heads are at.
I left Weaver off of the list strictly on size. Today’s Vandermeer action vindicates my choice.
Editor of The Copper & Blue, and leader of The Cult Of Hartikainen.
I also think that Smid is pretty much cemented into a top 4 role on this team regardless of what the stats may tell you. Plus, we’ll have at least one of the kids learning at the NHL level. The safe money is on one of Peckham or Chorney, but I don’t think you can completely rule out Motin or Plante either. I just hope it’s only 1.
Lydman would be one of my first choices. I believe he plays RD despite being a LH shot, which would be a good partner for Smid.
I still want Michalek, but I’m already coming to terms with the fact that we ’aint getting him.
I also think that Smid is pretty much cemented into a top 4 role on this team regardless of what the stats may tell you. Plus, we’ll have at least one of the kids learning at the NHL level. The safe money is on one of Peckham or Chorney, but I don’t think you can completely rule out Motin or Plante either. I just hope it’s only 1.
And you’re still signing Strudwick? With Strudwick, Vandermeer and Peckham/Chorney/Motin/Plante, there are three 7/8 defensemen on the team.
Editor of The Copper & Blue, and leader of The Cult Of Hartikainen.
In that all of Chorney, Motin and Plante can move freely to and from the AHL, this doesn’t strike me as a problem if the Oilers go with 13F and 8D to start the year (with Vandermeer, Strudwick and Peckham being the 6th, 7th and 8th D).
by Scott Reynolds on Jun 30, 2010 11:11 PM PDT up reply actions
Especially since both Vandermeer and Strudwick can play up front in a pinch. I don’t mind 13/8/2 or even (deep breath) 13/7/3 if need be.
Writer for The Copper & Blue and primary shareholder of Zorg Industries
"Never be ashamed of who you are" -- Jean-Baptiste Emanuel Zorg
by Bruce McCurdy on Jul 1, 2010 10:12 PM PDT up reply actions
Where did I say anything about Strudwick? For the record, I don’t think he comes back.
I’m predicting a spot is left open on D for one of the kids. I’d personally just as well leave them in the AHL until they prove to be too good for that league, but we’re a rebuilding team, and they’re going to want to get these guys’ feet wet this year.
I think this is an area where the Oilers should have some money to spend (so long as they move Souray). Gilbert and Whitney are good enough options on the PP and are a great second toughs pairing at EV, especially if you can put them in some offensive situations. What the Oilers need is a shut-down pairing for a combined $8.5M or so that’s ready to play well for 2011-12. They can’t wait on anyone in the system to fill those holes with the possible exception of Smid, but I don’t see him being effective in that role. That means, whale-hunting! They do have a couple of years, so there’s no need to rush in on July 1st but two very good players would be my goal. If it’s true that the Rangers are at an impasse with Marc Staal, that seems like a great place to start. I would be talking Sather’s ear off.
The issue from all accounts with Staal is the years. He’s not willing to take a long term deal because he wants to maintain his arbitration rights. So far he turned down 4yrs/14m, at least that’s the rumor.
He can likely be had (much to my chagrin), but I think the Rangers will match any offer sheet below the 1/2/3 threshold quickly. Whether he can be traded for is a question..but it’s going to require more than the Cogliano/Nilson/Moreau castoff triumvirate.
I still think it’s about 98% he re-signs.
Camp Tortorella - Where Vomit is a Mainstay
by George E. Ays on Jun 30, 2010 7:16 AM PDT up reply actions
If it were 100%, I feel it’d be done already. The fact that there is a gap does leave the small window someone will buck the RFA trend and throw a massive offer sheet at him. He is the reigning Langway Award winner after all.
Camp Tortorella - Where Vomit is a Mainstay
by George E. Ays on Jun 30, 2010 7:46 AM PDT up reply actions
The Oilers really can’t make an offer sheet to Staal effectively because risking their first round pick would seem like a poor idea. That said, I wasn’t expecting to get Staal for nothing. I’m not sure what exactly the Rangers would want, but I’d be willing to part with some good pieces, certainly more valuable than the chaff you mentioned above (although I actually like Cogliano).
by Scott Reynolds on Jun 30, 2010 10:09 AM PDT up reply actions
I just threw Cogliano in there because he’s always mentioned in possible Rangers-Oilers trades. I’m not sure what Sather would ask for. I mean, so far alone today I’ve seen Jussi Jokinen + another piece, Cody Hodgson, Bobby Ryan, part of a Spezza deal….ideas of his value are all over the map.
So does that mean MPS? Eberle? A lesser forward and Smid?
Camp Tortorella - Where Vomit is a Mainstay
by George E. Ays on Jun 30, 2010 1:57 PM PDT up reply actions
Well, a lesser forward (we’ll say Brule) and Smid is a slam dunk “yes” for the Oilers so that’s probably not enough. Smid and Eberle is something I’d need to think on but would likely be a “yes” for me. Smid and MPS would again be a thinker but would likely be a “no” because I have a pretty high opinion of Paajarvi. Of the offers you mentioned, I’d be inclined to think Bobby Ryan is probably the one worth considering.
by Scott Reynolds on Jun 30, 2010 5:55 PM PDT up reply actions
I have high regard for MPS also, I would certainly take him and Smid, so your ‘no’ is not a surprise. Eberle/Smid is probably right approx what his value should be, I think I would say yes also, but I’d have to sit on it for a few days.
Camp Tortorella - Where Vomit is a Mainstay
by George E. Ays on Jun 30, 2010 7:09 PM PDT up reply actions
You’re under-estimating Smid, IMO. Your stats tell you he’s not up to it, I suspect. My stats, and my eye, tell me he’s solid in the Top Four. We’ll see who is right.
by David Staples @ The Cult of Hockey on Jun 30, 2010 7:57 AM PDT reply actions
The thing with Smid is he’s not going to be a PP guy so he needs to be great on the PK and as a shut-down guy at EV. Can he handle tough minutes at EV? I don’t know, but I doubt it. I hope we find out this year.
by Scott Reynolds on Jun 30, 2010 10:10 AM PDT up reply actions
Colaiacovo is an interesting suggestion.
If we can all learn to spell “Paajarvi” with hardly a second thought, we’re up for a player like this on the Oilers.
The crazy thing here is that Tamby seems wedded to Strudwick, still, just as he still is to Jacques. But having gotten rid of O’Sullivan, perhaps he’s willing to axe some on his favourites.
by David Staples @ The Cult of Hockey on Jun 30, 2010 8:01 AM PDT reply actions
I’ve always liked Tallinder and Lyndman. They’re both solid if unspectacular defensemen. We could use a couple of those right now.
Same with Grossman. I’ll take three of them right now.
Editor of The Copper & Blue, and leader of The Cult Of Hartikainen.
Freddy Meyer is my pick. Though I’ve never seen him play that I can recall. . . Love his hits/blocked shots, though. Of course, even when Jason Smith could no longer play, he still had a lot of hits, blocked shots, but I believe Meyer also put up a few more points than Smith in his last gasp seasons.
by David Staples @ The Cult of Hockey on Jun 30, 2010 8:31 AM PDT up reply actions
Martin is going to get a big contract somewhere (Carolina?) and someone will overpay Mitchell.
Editor of The Copper & Blue, and leader of The Cult Of Hartikainen.
Michalek is the gem in there…. he is just a solid defensive defenseman (kinda like Hejda who we gave away). However, I doubt the Oil will sign him… in fact, I’m curious to see who they get as it’ll probably be not on that list at all.
What are the options from European teams? Are the Oilers allowed to steal players?
yeah, Michalek (as well as Hamhuis, IMO) are the really intriguing guys. based on Hamhuis being traded twice already, though, I suspect they’re gonna get seriously paid tomorrow. they’d be great additions to any team, but I’m not sure how much value they’ll provide.
by Passive Voice on Jun 30, 2010 11:56 AM PDT up reply actions
Ah...Chris Higgins.
Yeah he’s due to bounce back, but he’ll frustrate the hell out of you even though everything looks like he’s doing the right things, both visually and statistically.
Camp Tortorella - Where Vomit is a Mainstay
by George E. Ays on Jun 30, 2010 1:53 PM PDT up reply actions
How could I? He wasn’t even on the list. Derek dropped the ball again.
Writer for The Copper & Blue and primary shareholder of Zorg Industries
"Never be ashamed of who you are" -- Jean-Baptiste Emanuel Zorg
by Bruce McCurdy on Jun 30, 2010 7:12 PM PDT up reply actions
I’ve only got MacGregor’s ear. The pro scouts…clearly not so much.
Editor of The Copper & Blue, and leader of The Cult Of Hartikainen.

by 
























