2009 NHL Draft: Revisiting 1998 and 1999 and 2000 (Updated)

I've been talking a lot about using percentage of team offense as a measuring stick for draft-eligible players, but I haven't shown any proof that it works.  Tonight, I decided I'd revisit the 1998 Draft; I was going to go 10 years back to 1999, but the fact of the matter is that 1999 was a garbage draft, and so 1998 is probably a better measuring stick (I'll get to 1999 in time).

Here is the list of forwards grabbed in the first round out of the Canadian junior leagues, in order:

  1. Vincent Lecavalier
  2. David Legwand
  3. Rico Fata
  4. Manny Malhotra
  5. Mark Bell
  6. Mike Rupp
  7. Jeff Heerema
  8. Alex Tanguay
  9. Michael Henrich
  10. Eric Chouinard
  11. Scott Parker
  12. Simon Gagne
  13. Scott Gomez

Looking at that list, who would we move up?  Probably Tanguay, Gagne, and Gomez, right?  Here's the list again, this time ranked by each player's percentage of their team's total offense.  As always, I calculate this by dividing a players point totals by his team's total goals for (adjusted for games played).

  1. Vincent Lecavalier (46.9%)
  2. Alex Tanguay (44.2%)
  3. David Legwand (42.1%)
  4. Simon Gagne (32.0%)
  5. Eric Chouinard (30.0%)
  6. Jeff Heerema (29.8%)
  7. Scott Gomez (29.7%)
  8. Michael Henrich (26.7%)
  9. Rico Fata (25.4%)
  10. Mark Bell (25.2%)
  11. Manny Malhotra (22.4%)
  12. Mike Rupp (9.7%)
  13. Scott Parker (2.3%)

Which of those rankings better reflects NHL achievement?  I think the bottom one, by a country mile.  For starters, it shows the culpable stupidity of the New York Islanders and Colorado Avalanche, respectively, for blowing high picks on Mike Rupp (9th overall) and Scott Parker (re-entered the draft, 20th overall).

It's absolutely inexcusable that this simple calculation outperformed NHL scouts at the 1998 draft.  But lets go one step further and look at the guys in later rounds who went on to have great careers.  Does percentage of offense do as good a job with them?  Here's my list, taken from HockeyDB:

Here are those players again, this time ranked by percentage of total team offense:

  1. Brad Richards (40.0%)
  2. Mike Ribeiro (38.6%)
  3. Michael Ryder (23.3%)
  4. Trent Hunter (10.4%)

Mixed results here.  This method did a fine job of showing that Richards and Ribeiro should both have been first-round players based on their offense, but completely missed the boat on Hunter and didn't show Ryder as an offensive guy at the NHL level.

I'm going to keep looking into this, but I'm very excited about these initial results.  I'm also a little shocked; I know this is just one sample and isn't conclusive, but I would never have imagined this scale as beating NHL scouts at anything.

1999 NHL Draft

Since I had some more time on my hands, I decided I'd also run the numbers from 1999.  Just to see.  Here's the draft order of all Canadian junior forwards grabbed in the first round:

  1. Pavel Brendl
  2. Tim Connolly
  3. Kris Beech
  4. Taylor Pyatt
  5. Jamie Lundmark
  6. Oleg Saprykin
  7. Denis Shvidki
  8. Scott Kelman

Not much to pick from, unfortunately.  In any case, here they are again by percentage of offense:

  1. Pavel Brendl (44.5%)
  2. Tim Connolly (37.1%)
  3. Oleg Saprykin (36.4%)
  4. Jamie Lundmark (32.1%)
  5. Denis Shvidki (30.6%)
  6. Taylor Pyatt (28.7%)
  7. Scott Kelman (28.5%)
  8. Kris Beech (22.2%)

This method didn't manage to avoid the Pavel Brendl pick either, but in fairness it really didn't do much worse.  1999 was just a miserable draft year; certainly the worst of my lifetime.  As for overachievers, I spotted just one out of major junior, Radim Vrbata who went 212th overall out of the QMJHL.  His percentage of offense score was 28.2%; not great, but not bad either.  I'd call this second draft examination a wash.

2000 NHL Draft 

Round Three.  Here again is the list of forwards taken out of Canadian junior leagues during the first round of the 2000 NHL Entry Draft:

  1. Raffi Torres
  2. Scott Hartnell
  3. Nikita Alexeev
  4. Marcel Hossa
  5. Nathan Smith
  6. Brad Boyes
  7. Steve Ott
  8. Brian Sutherby
  9. Justin Williams

The guys worth moving up are pretty obvious here: Boyes, Williams, and to a lesser extent Ott, I think.  Let's apply our formula to the order and see what it spits out.

  1. Scott Hartnell (43.1%)
  2. Raffi Torres (42.7%)
  3. Marcel Hossa (36.8%)
  4. Brad Boyes (36.6%)
  5. Justin Williams (32.4%)
  6. Steve Ott (30.0%)
  7. Nikita Alexeev (25.1%)
  8. Brian Sutherby (24.3%)
  9. Nathan Smith (19.6%)

Based on the numbers, none of Alexeev, Sutherby, or Smith should have been first rounders.  Fun coincidence: based on reality, none of Alexeev, Sutherby, or Smith should have been first rounders.  This list also flips Hartnell for Torres, which is an improvement, and moves up Boyes, Williams and Ott.  Obviously, the list isn't perfect, but as with the 1998 group, it is an improvement.

What about the guys who slipped down the draft rankings?  Here's my list, again from HockeyDB:

Let's apply our formula and take a look:

  1. Jarret Stoll (27.7%)
  2. Antoine Vermette (25.2%)
  3. Michel Ouellet (24.1%)
  4. Matthew Lombardi (17.0%)

The results are once again mixed, but for the most part (Lombardi excepted) I think show fair value for the level of offense these players developed.

We're three drafts into this analysis, and by my count Math has beat scouting in two drafts and washed in the third.  I'm a statistics guy, but I still find this a little shocking.

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join The Copper & Blue

You must be a member of The Copper & Blue to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at The Copper & Blue. You should read them.

Join The Copper & Blue

You must be a member of The Copper & Blue to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at The Copper & Blue. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9355_tracker