Reactions: From Players and Media
Two and a half hours after Steve Tambellini's press conference where he announced that Craig MacTavish was no longer employed as head coach by the Edmonton Oilers, the Oilers scheduled a press conference with two veterans who both played under MacTavish for a number of seasons: Ethan Moreau and Steve Staios.
Unfortunately, the press conference was a bit of a disaster; after half an hour of waiting, which was punctuated by various reporters going up to the microphone and amusing themselves ("Marc Crawford is the next head coach of the Edmonton Oilers!") the players finally appeared. Unfortunately, the audio disappeared at the same time, and the press conference morphed into a scrum.
Fortunately for us, though, Joanne Ireland did some quick typing and the comments of Moreau and Staios are now up at faceoff.com. Staios made some fairly vanilla comments, but Ethan Moreau's comments grabbed my attention:
I don't think anybody's terrible surprised. We knew changes had to be made and this is the first one," Moreau said. "We have to get better in a lot of areas and it starts with the players. We fully accept that challenge and that responsibility... We need to change the culture and change the environment. We have to get back that pride we had in the organization. And win. Win games. Make the playoffs. Win playoff series."
My initial reaction was that if change starts with the players, why did the first change have to be the removal of the head coach?
My second thought was that if the team's culture and pride are serious issues that need to be changed, why is Ethan Moreau the guy pointing it out? Moreau's been the team captain for two seasons now; two seasons where much of the roster hasn't changed and the guys who frequently found themselves in the doghouse (Penner, Nilsson, Brodziak, Pouliot) have played for this team.
In other words, if there's a problem with this team's culture and pride, at least some of the blame should be directed at the team's ostensible leader - Ethan Moreau.
That is, of course, if you buy Moreau's notion that pride and culture were the key issues with this team - which I don't particularly. Every team has problems - even Stanley Cup champions. I finished reading Douglas Hunter's biography of Scotty Bowman this past weekend, and the things his former players say about him are shocking; there's a lot of hatred there, even though Bowman was so successful.
No, I think the real problem with this team was a lack of experienced forwards who could play in both the offensive and defensive zones. There were just too many young players to shelter - most of whom are small to begin with - and that, more than anything else, led to the disappointing result this season. Sure, culture, pride and coaching decisions all played a part (and MacTavish has paid for those and it seems to me that the leadership group in the dressing room should to if the issues are as serious as Moreau has stated they are), but at the end of the day, the team icing a half-dozen unreliable players is going to lose more often than not.
The other reaction I thought was interesting was Michael Russo's (h/t to Pierre LeBrun). Russo suggested that the Wild should move quickly to interview MacTavish "before somebody else snatches him up". Tambellini said in his press conference that he rather expected Craig MacTavish to be coaching in the NHL next season, and I think Oilers fans as a whole have rarely given MacTavish credit for what he is: a smart, capable coach who is certainly worthy of an NHL job.
I doubt that Russo is the only one who feels this way; I'd be very surprised if Craig MacTavish was not standing behind an NHL bench at some point next season.
0 recs |
13 comments
|
Comments
great post JW. I agree, Mac was a great coach and a great guy to have in the city. He will be missed and I for one have little doubt that he will take another team down a very successful road. I would just hate to see him in Minnesota, as playing against him 6 times a year would be hard to handle I think.
That being said, I think you might be on to something regarding leadership, especially the leadership of our current captain. If he is the one being so critical of the culture and player accountability, why on earth did he not take his own actions to task this year. A prime example, above and beyond the foolishly courageous move of playing with a broken hand, would be the game where he called out the powerplay as the problem, after it went 1/4 and the pk, Moreau’s supposed bread and butter allowed 3 ppgs against. That is not strong leadership. As much as the team needs his grit some nights, I think he might be another great Oiler whose time has come and gone. If Tambo’s intentions are what they seem to be, this afternoon will be the first phase of many purges. I think thecaptainethanmoreau (sadly) might be one of the next to go.
by shepso on Apr 15, 2009 6:24 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I doubt Moreau gets dealt...
Just because if there’s one player who fits the holes hte Oilers are trying to fill (size, grit, experience) it’s him.
It's only my opinion, but it's right.
by Jonathan Willis on Apr 15, 2009 6:44 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I’m inclined to agree that he is one of those players who fills that specific role, but perhaps he could be shipped out for two younger parts that fit the role as well. I don’t have a hate for Moreau, despite some of the things I’ve said on my blog, I just think he’s as much a part of the problem of the culture here as anyone else who has been thrown under the bus. He doesn’t lead by example, and the things he says are not becoming of a captain. Maybe don’t trade him, but consider stripping him of the C under the regime change, if it is deemed necessary. Modano took the demotion with grace and class in Dallas, and the fact is, Morrow turned into a really great captain down there. I think it’s time for a new king of the jungle, one who’s less injury prone and more of a complete player. As I said in my post the other day, he is gritty and fearless (good) but selfish and dumb (bad).
by shepso on Apr 15, 2009 7:04 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I don't like Moreau
For a lot of reasons, mostly the gets outchanced/takes stupid penalties combo, and on a more juvenile not he’s always struck me as casually arrogant.
But he does fit the needs of this team.
It's only my opinion, but it's right.
by Jonathan Willis on Apr 15, 2009 7:59 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Glencross
We need to locate a Curtis Glencross type of player. Liam Reddox is good but he’s no firebrand yet. I think near the top of our wishlist has gotta be a checking line centerman.
by raventalon40 on Apr 15, 2009 9:34 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Needs
Colby Armstrong and Ryan Callahan do too.
There are other options available
by Derek Zona on Apr 15, 2009 8:42 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Armstrong quietly had a real nice season in Atlanta. I’m not sure they’re looking to get rid of him.
by James Mirtle on Apr 15, 2009 11:02 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I’ve always like Colby Armstrong. But I like Kovalchuk and Reasoner better.
by raventalon40 on Apr 15, 2009 11:10 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Realistically
Armstrong and Reasoner are alot more attainable the Kovalchyuk is.
by Discipline on Apr 16, 2009 9:27 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Not realistic – but not impossible. If Kovalchuk were available in some capacity – any capacity, I’m sure any GM would try to acquire him.
As for Reasoner, if he doesn’t resign in Atlanta (like he sounds like he wants to do) he should return to Edmonton. I’ve never seen him play himself out of a job and the only time where it seemed appropriate to get rid of him was when we were getting Samsonov in return.
by raventalon40 on Apr 16, 2009 4:05 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Thecaptainethanmoreau
Was out of the loop yesterday but just heard the Moreau/Staios interviews on the radio. Wasn’t terribly impressed by either. I was more than a little put off (again) by Moreau’s self-serving remarks, the gist of which seemed to be “if everybody was as professional as me, there’d be no problem”. Maybe I’m reading more into his comments than I should, but it’s far from the first time I have noticed this. For a team leader there’s a frightening shortage of “We” in his remarks, at least when it’s anything remotely to do with accountability.
http:www.oildroppings.blogspot.com
by Bruce McCurdy on Apr 16, 2009 10:07 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Didn’t you hear? He took his non-coincidental fighting major because he had a broken hand.
SNN Sports - A theoretical Oilers blog (i.e. theoretically, I write stuff there)
by Doogie2K on Apr 16, 2009 12:34 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 























